Cinder Block vs Concrete Block: What Is the Difference?

Building a fire pit, retaining wall, cold cellar or foundation wall, requires planning and the proper materials. Choosing cinder block vs. concrete block may determine how strenuous the build will be, and how long your project will last. Your success may be in their differences.

Cinder blocks are light-weight low-density building blocks made of cement and coal ash. Concrete blocks combine cement with sand and gravel, and a small percentage of cinders. Cinder blocks lack the strength and resistance to weather and pressure that concrete blocks possess, and aren’t recommended for many load-bearing jobs.

In this article, we’ll explore cinder and concrete blocks, their history, specifications, uses, and compare the different types currently available. By the conclusion of the reading, you should have a better understanding of which type of block to use for your project.

Some Background

The art of making concrete, invented by the Romans around 300BCE, was lost when their empire fell. The redevelopment of concrete began in 1756, but the modern formula wasn’t patented until 1824. Although not as durable as the lost Roman formula, it was more portable and less expensive than quarried stone blocks.

From the 1830s onward, different patents were issued for concrete block making machines – some of which produced blocks weighing 180 pounds! In 1889, a mold for solid concrete blocks was issued to Harmond S. Palmer of Tennessee, and in 1899 he patented the hollow concrete block machine. These blocks were lighter and less expensive to produce and are the foundation of the modern concrete block.

Hand casting 1,200 to 4,000 blocks for a foundation, however, would have been labor-intensive, grueling back-breaking work for two people over several weeks. A highly automated cement block plant today can easily manufacture several 1000 blocks an hour, ensuring concrete blocks are readily available for multiple projects.

What Is a Cinder Block

Cinder Block

Cinder blocks are light-weight low-density construction blocks, or concrete masonry units (CMU). They are manufactured from a mixture of Portland cement and an aggregate of cinders from burned coal; hence, their name. The mixture is poured or pressed into molds and either heated to dry, or air-dried. Cinder blocks commonly have two or three hollow cores in the middle.

Portland cement, invented in 1824 in England, is made by heating limestone and mineral clay to form clinker, which is then ground into a powder and mixed with 2% to 3% gypsum. The cinders are the fly or bottom ash left from burning coal for different purposes. The fine ash is also known as breeze in the United Kingdom, which is why they are called breeze blocks in the UK.

The process of using coal ash was invented in 1913 by Francis Straub, a brick mason in Pittsburgh, who had experimented with waste ash from the coal and steel plants as an aggregate to produce a lighter brick. After several years of experimenting, he arrived at the best mixture ratio, and the cinder block was born. The blocks are light-weight, provide some insulating value, and nails can be hammered into them.

Masons found the lighter weight easier to lift and maneuver on scaffolds, or for lifting and threading over rebar. The hollow cores make it easy to reinforce the cinder block construction by filling the cores with concrete.

The fireproof blocks were used in all facets of construction, from foundation to interior walls. Cinder blocks had many uses in the construction industry until about 50 years ago when poured concrete wall construction became more common.

Today, 12 million tons of coal ash or cinder is used as a strengthening agent to make light-weight concrete blocks. Cinder blocks are still used today but are prohibited in some building applications under building codes. The blocks are prone to moisture damage, buckling, bowing, and lack the tensile and shear strength of concrete blocks.

Another drawback to cinder blocks was the toxic nature of the coal ash used in their manufacture. The toxins are linked to nervous disorders, cancer, health complaints, and decreased cognitive ability.

Today, the lighter cinder blocks are used in walls in large construction projects where their weight is a bonus, and they don’t have to carry any load. They are often used in alternating patterns with concrete blocks to reduce weight without weakening the construction. The hollow-core blocks are still used in some foundations and other construction applications, landscaping, gardening, fire pit and place construction, benches, and hundreds of other locations and uses.

Although ash is less commonly used as an aggregate replacement today in blocks, it is used as a mixing agent in most blocks, and to lighten Group 2 concrete blocks. The term ‘cinder block’ has come to mean light-weight low-density blocks, and more confusingly, to be synonymous with any hollow core concrete block. When purchasing lighter cinder blocks today, the seller should be able to tell you if they contain ash or pumice.

Types of Cinder Blocks

Types of cinder blocks

Today, there are at least 32 different shapes and dimensions of cinder block. They are divided into pier, stretcher, sash, hollow return corner, and 45° angle. The dimensions range from 4”x4”x8” to 8”x12”x16”, with angle blocks reaching up to 21” long.

  • Pier blocks can be different standard sizes and are solid pier or hollow pier. Their faces are all smooth or finished. 
  • Stretcher blocks are made to join other stretcher blocks, so their ends are half hollowed, and their sides are smooth. There are solid and hollow-core stretchers.
  • Sash blocks can be solid, hollow, corner, single, or double and are used to face window openings in block walls.
  • Hollow return corner blocks simplify joining two walls with a brick weave at the corner.
  • 45° angle blocks make angle wall construction easier and more solid.

Weight of Cinder Blocks

Although cinder blocks have come to mean any hollow-core concrete block, we’re referring to those that are true cinder blocks. Lightweight blocks that use ash or pumice weigh less than standard aggregate blocks of similar size and shape that use gravel or stone as the aggregate.

A light-weight cinder or pumice hollow-core 8’x8’x16 stretcher block weighs approximately 28 pounds. It is about 10-pounds lighter than a standard concrete block of equal dimensions. Cinder blocks of different shapes and sizes will also be lighter than similar concrete blocks.

What Is the Size of a Cinder Block

Cinder blocks come in 4”, 6”, 8” and 12” thicknesses (widths) and 2”, 4” and 8” heights. The 8-inch height matches three rows of standard clay bricks, and the 16-inch length compares to 2 brick lengths. This allows bricks and blocks to be laid in paired courses and line up for window and door openings.

A standard concrete masonry unit (CMU), or standard block shape, also known as the square 8, is nominally 8”x8”x16” but is actually 7-5/8”x7-5/8”x15-5/8” in size. The difference allows for 3/8” of mortar to fill the gaps to achieve the 8” height and 16” length.

Where to Get Cinder Blocks

Today, most building supply stores carry ‘cinder’ blocks that are actually hollow-core concrete blocks with some ash content. To purchase lightweight blocks containing ash as the aggregate may involve a special order at most stores.

Local concrete block and brick manufacturers are more likely to have some in stock or will run a special order and cut out the middleman. You may also find old cinder blocks at renovation or rebuild stores.

How Much Do Cinder Blocks Cost

Today, old formula cinder blocks are more common near coal-burning plants, those further away have to ship in coal ash or pumice and so use it as a mixing agent instead of an aggregate. If you’re lucky, you may find an internet buy-sell-trade site listing used cinder blocks taken from older building demolition sites for $0.25 to $1 each.

Hollow-core 8”x8”x16” cinder blocks containing 25% to 40% ash will cost between $1.50 and $2.00 US at most building supply stores. Purchasing light-weight blocks of the same size that use ash as an aggregate may cost 5 to 10 times more depending on your location and the number of blocks being ordered.

What Is Concrete Block

Concrete Block

A concrete block, or concrete masonry unit (CMU), commonly refers to an 8”x8”x16” block used in construction. The blocks are stronger, denser, and heavier than cinder blocks.

They are manufactured using a 1:6 ratio of Portland cement to aggregate, with 60% of the aggregate being fine material like sand and the remaining 40% being coarse material like finely crushed stone or gravel. The mix is poured, pressed, or cast into molds and cured.

Portland cement is mixed with water to form a concrete slurry of one to two parts Portland cement with one part water. The mix is thickened to the consistency of tempera paint – thick and pasty – and added to the aggregate. Alternatively, the cement and aggregates are dry mixed, and then water added to form the desired consistency. The mix is then cast into blocks of standard sizes and weights.

Patents for making concrete blocks appeared in the 1830s for blocks being manufactured on building sites. The precast blocks were laid like common clay bricks but could be laid more quickly to form walls. They were cheaper, quicker, and easier to use than quarried stone blocks too. The first house built completely from precast blocks in the US was on Staten Island in 1837.

The Frear Stone Manufacturing Company patented a decorative concrete block that was less expensive and quicker to produce than carved stone blocks. The Chicago Company was the first commercial enterprise for precast concrete blocks. After the 1871 Chicago fire, the blocks became more popular as a fire-resistant building material since those in use survived the flames.

Manufacturing of blocks on a large scale for distribution began in earnest with the use of the cast-iron hollow-core concrete block making machine patented by Harmon Palmer in 1900. By the end of the 1920s, more than 1000 companies and contractors had constructed hundreds of thousands of homes had using precast hollow-core blocks. The Sears Roebuck Company even sold a rock face and smooth finish block making machine for $57.50 that was very popular between 1905 and 1920.

Concrete blocks proved fire and weather-resistant, and are used to build foundations, walls, floors, ceilings, commercial structures, and silos. They also provide heat and sound insulation properties and long service life.

According to the Masonry Standards Joint Committee’s requirements for building codes, the CMU must withstand a minimum of 1,000 psi to 5500 psi of compression. Unreinforced hollow-core blocks have shear strength, average tensile, and flexural tensile strength of approximately 10% of their compressive strength.

Concrete Block Types

Concrete blocks come in different classifications, types, and shapes. Blocks may be classified by their voids – solid (no void), cellular (void doesn’t go all the way through), and hollow. They can be high-density blocks that contain sand and tiny gravel aggregates, or low-density blocks that contain varying amounts of coal ash.

Hollow core or cellular blocks have between 50% and 75% of the total mass of a solid core block with similar dimensions, making them lighter than the solid block.

There are several different classifications of concrete block too – Group 1 or Grade A, Group 2 or Grade B, Group 3 or Grade C. Grade A are hollow-core blocks having a minimum density of 1500 kg/m³ and contain less than 25% cinders. They have a compressive strength of 3.5, 4.5, 5.5, 7.0, 8.5, 10.0, 12.5 and 15.0 N/mm2 depending on dimensions and what they are manufactured for.

Grade B is lighter weight hollow core blocks with a density between 1100 and 1500 kg/m³, contain between 25% and 40% cinders, have a compressive strength between 3.5 and 5.0 N/mm2 and aren’t rated for load-bearing construction. Grade A is also more fir- resistant than Grade B blocks. Grade C blocks are solid core, have a density greater than 1800 kg/m³, and have a minimum compressive strength between 4 and 5.0 N/mm2.

There are eight different types of concrete blocks available in different dimensions. There are solid or hollow core, stretcher, corner, lintel, partition, pillar, jamb, frogged, bullnose, and square blocks.

  • Solid blocks are heavy and dense and are commonly used for load-bearing walls. They are available in most shapes, similar to hollow-core shapes.
  • Stretcher blocks fill in between corner and jamb blocks. They are the most common hollow core block.
  • Corner blocks have a smooth finished end for door, window, or passage openings, and a stretcher end to tie in with the wall construction.
  • Lintel, channel, or beam blocks are U-shaped. The ‘U’ is filled with rebar and concrete to form a lintel or beam that transfers the downward load.
  • Partition blocks are usually narrower than their height and provide a fire break. The hollow core also helps reduce noise transfer.
  • Pillar blocks are smooth-faced on all sides for use as finished posts, piers, or pillars.
  • Jamb blocks are notched to provide space for window or door casings.
  • Bullnose blocks have rounded corners on one end to soften their use to end walls that form alcoves, passage openings, partition ends, or entrances.
  • Frogged blocks have a cellular center grove to hold more mortar or concrete for a stronger bond to the next layer.

Hollow square concrete blocks are used to fabricate chimneys or to form walls or garden retaining walls or boxes. Solid squares are commonly used for foundation blocks or retaining walls.

What Is the Size of a Concrete Block

Concrete blocks come in standardized thicknesses (widths) of 2”, 4”, 6”, 8”, and 12” and heights of 2”, 4” and 8”. The common stretcher of 16” length and 8” height has the same area as six common clay bricks, making it easy to cover the blocks with brick veneer.

A concrete masonry unit (CMU) is nominally 2”, 4”, 6”, 8”, 10” and 12” wide by 8” high and 16” long. Half-blocks are only 8” long. Actual dimensions are 3/8” narrower to allow for mortar placement. A standard stretcher would actually be 7-5/8”x7-5/8”x15-5/8” instead of 8”x8”x16”.

Weight of Concrete Blocks

The weight of different concrete blocks depends upon their dimension, density, and group or grade. Larger blocks of similar density will weigh more than smaller dimensions, while light-weight will be lighter than heavy, dense blocks of the same size.

A 4”x8”x16” hollow block is 27 lbs, and a solid is 36 lbs, the 6”x8”x16” hollow is 32 lbs, and a solid is 50 lbs. A hollow-core 8”x 8”x16” stretcher block weighs 38 to 40 lbs, and a solid 8”x8”x16” block weighs 70 lbs. If you’re feeling strong, the12”x8”x16” solid block tops out at 105 pounds.

How Much Are Concrete Blocks

Solid cement block prices are slightly more than the lighter hollow-core costs. Both styles of blocks are available at most building supply stores and at local manufacturers. The price will depend on where you reside. Purchasing large volumes of blocks often decreases the cost per unit, but may require delivery.

A solid 4”x8”x16 will cost approximately $1.65 while a hollow is $1.20 to $1.55. A solid 8”x8”x16” stretcher is$1.50 to $1.95 and the hollow between $1.20 and $1.85. Prices and availability depend on the store and location and may require a special order.

Cinder Block vs Concrete Block

Cinder Block vs Concrete Block

Comparing cinder blocks and concrete blocks is a good way to determine which type of block is best for your project. Cinder blocks using coal ash as an aggregate are not as widely produced as they were 50 years ago but are still available in some areas.

However, the term ‘cinder block’ has been used to mean lighter weight, hollow core concrete blocks. The ‘lighter’ blocks use sand and tiny gravel aggregate but also contain between 25% and 40% ash.

Load bearing blocks contain some ash as a mixing agent and non-load bearing concrete blocks have greater amounts of ash content. Load bearing blocks are available in hollow-core and solid core blocks, while the lighter blocks commonly have 2 or 3 cores. The chart below compares cinder blocks with concrete blocks.

Cinder BlocksConcrete Blocks
Made of Portland cement and cinders (ash) from burned coal.Made of Portland cement, sand, and tiny or crushed stone or gravel.
Cast and have a rough or porous texture.Are cast to have a smoother or quarried stone look and have a less porous texture.
Rectangular blocks with 2 or 3 hollow cores.Rectangular blocks with 2 or 3 hollow cores, flattened cores, or solid.
The ash aggregate makes for lighter blocks.Sand and stone aggregate make blocks heavier.
Lack tensile strength so don’t hold up against pressure, and are less durable.Greater tensile strength, withstand pressure and force.
Blocks are more ‘flexible’ and can bend under pressure – prohibited in some construction by building codes.Much stronger and more durable than cinder blocks.
Common nominal dimensions of 2”, 4”, 6”, 8”, 10” and 12” wide by 2”, 4” and 8” high and 8” or 16” long.Common nominal dimensions of 2”, 4”, 6”, 8”, 10” and 12” wide by 2”, 4” and 8” high and 8” or 16” long.
Actual measurements are 3/8” narrower than the nominal measurements.Actual measurements are 3/8” narrower than the nominal measurements.
Hasn’t been mass produced in the past 50 years, but concrete blocks containing 25-40% ash are, and are known as ‘cinder’ blocksWidely manufactured and readily available today.
Ash content and hollow core produces very good fire and insulating factors.Concrete blocks have lower fire and insulating factors.
Weight of a 8x8x16 hollow core is 28 lbsA 8”x 8”x16” hollow block weighs 38 to 40 lbs, and a solid block weighs 70 lbs.
Cost depends on dimensions – $1.20 to $1.90Cost depends on dimensions – $1.20 to $2.11
Doesn’t withstand forces of nature well and requires more repair.Withstands the elements and forces of nature better and requires less maintenance.
Although initially widely used, today are more common in small projects, non-bearing walls, fireplace or pit construction, and landscaping.Used in small to massive construction projects, plus landscaping, and retaining and garden walls.

 

Conclusion

Making a choice between cinder blocks or concrete blocks is less of an issue today as blocks using ash as the aggregate aren’t very common. The term ‘cinder’, though, is commonly used to identify light-weight low-density Group 2 blocks with 25 to 40% ash content. For structural load bearing concrete blocks, Group 1 or 3 blocks are recommended.

We hope you have a better understanding of how cinder blocks differ from concrete blocks, and of their different uses. If you found the article helpful or interesting, please share it with others. As always, we appreciate your comments and suggestions.

Leave a Comment